When I went to Turkey, some of my students were given
substitute/replacement instructors. Some chose to wait. I knew that even when
those classes ended, I would not necessarily get them back: generally the
trainer who has a class when it officially ends gets first priority in the
renewal. I knew and was OK with that.
Recently it got back to me that one of the students I gave up had “really liked
me”, but was “happy to keep her new teacher” because “she’s Asian” (Australian
of Cantonese descent) and she feels more comfortable with a teacher of Asian
heritage – or, to be blunt, in the words I was actually told, “another woman
who looks like her”.
Now, I realize that this was secondhand information and
there’s no guarantee that my former student’s true sentiments were reflected in
this game of telephone. I also realize that the person who told me might well
have been trying to protect my feelings by not saying that, regardless of race,
she just preferred the new trainer (which, you know, it happens. Oh well). The
person who told me is pretty blunt, though, and the student in question and I
had a very good, friendly, dare I say ‘close’ relationship. So…who knows.
What’s interesting is the reaction when I mentioned this on
Facebook – when it happened, I felt a bit hurt. Not so much at the possibility
that a student would prefer another trainer (although that sucks, I figure it’s
a lot like finding a good therapist: even the best ones don’t click with every
patient and it’s a patient’s right to find one they ‘click’ with. It doesn’t
mean that the one they left was bad). More at the idea that, despite liking me
quite a bit, learning a lot and enjoying the class, if my intuition that we’d
had a good relationship had been correct, that I’d be passed over simply because
I’m white, not Asian.
I
realize people face this all the time in the otherdirection – schools and other employers regularly discriminate against
Westerners of Asian heritage - and it’s a lot worse going that way. I’m not
trying to detract from that or trying for a condescending “I know how you
feel”. Just adding my experience. A lot of discussion on racism in English teaching in Taiwan is about discriminating against English teachers who don't look Western - while that's a far more serious problem, I do feel a different perspective based on different experience is valuable.
Generally speaking my Western friends didn’t comment much –
but my Taiwanese friends sure did!
And here’s the thing: if you take as a given that the
student did, in fact like me and there is no missing information, and it is in
fact true that another instructor was chosen purely on the basis of that
instructor’s race compared to mine, I personally feel that’s a form of racism,
or if you want a less loaded term, “racial discrimination”. I mean it’s judging
someone and making a decision based 100% on race – how is that not
discrimination?
My Taiwanese friends generally felt differently, though
- few chimed in with agreement that it
just sucks, and nobody should judge people based on skin tone, and it stinks
that people still feel this way regarding race (which many undoubtedly do).
Most came out and said that they did not, in fact, consider
that situation to be “racism”. I’m still at a slight loss as to why, because
with one exception from one very eloquent friend whom I routinely mistake for
being a native speaker of English (she did go to high school and college
abroad, though), all of the reasons given still struck me as, well, as racism.
Or “racial discrimination”. Or whatever.
Which may be a bit of culture difference I’ll never get over. I’m not even sure
I want to.
The very eloquent answer: that, despite this other teacher
being culturally Australian despite looking Asian, that with her family roots
in Hong Kong, there would be some sort of gut-level cultural synergy between
her and the student that I could not pick up on, because as someone with zero
ties to “Chinese culture” besides living here for 5+ years, I wouldn’t have it.
There might be cultural concordance that, while not easy to articulate, is
there on some fundamental level that makes the student feel more comfortable.
OK, I can buy that. Race isn’t just about race, after all,
it’s about culture – and even though I consider anyone born in whatever
country, regardless of their family history, to be of that country (so a kid
with Chinese parents born in Canada, to me, is Canadian), that they will have
cultural ties and cultural traits passed down from their parents that I don’t.
I mean, I have that, and my most recently emigrated relative is my grandfather.
I have ties to Armenian, especially Armenian-diaspora-from-Turkey, culture that
are on some level hard to explain to others. Hell, I even planned an entire
seven-week trip around returning to Mousa Dagh to see where I come from.
Looking out from that gorgeous orange-tree dotted mountain out to the
Mediterranean below is and will continue to be one of the most memorable
moments of my life. My grandfather practically cried when I gave him a framed
picture of me in the last remaining Armenian village on the mountain.
Although, I couldn’t help but think when we discussed it,
that if you’re going to learn a foreign language then you’re kinda-sorta
obligated to interact with the culture that comes with that language. In my
heart of hearts I do feel it’s sort of a cop-out to want to learn English but
interact with other Asians, avoiding the Big White Other as much as possible.
It’s really not any better than foreigners coming to Taiwan to learn Chinese
and then hanging out almost exclusively with other foreigners (except for maybe
a local girlfriend). I can almost-sorta understand that, though, as many people
in that situation
would probably like to make more local friends, but havetrouble doing so.
On the other hand, I’ve said a few times that I’m going to
leave my job fairly soon (this is an open secret so I’m not worried about
saying so here), and one of the reasons is that I would really either prefer to
work for myself, or have a foreign boss – I just can’t take the constant
sandpaper-like scratchy-scratchy culture clash of having an overseas Chinese
(not Taiwanese) boss who treats foreigners like they’re Chinese employees and
then gets flustered when we don’t act in accordance with that. So…OK. I kind of
get it.
Otherwise, I do have to say, I got a bunch of stuff I’d
still label as “racist”.
One friend said “if I were a Chinese teacher in the USA and
a student wanted an American teacher and not me, I would not consider it
discrimination.” Really? Because I would.
One said “Maybe she wanted the Asian teacher because her
English is not good” (it is, but that’s not the point) “and she thinks she can
speak Chinese with the new one.” Nice try, but I speak far better Mandarin than
the new teacher, and is it not racist to assume that someone who looks Asian
will necessarily speak better Chinese than someone who does not?
(To digress a bit, but in related news, I do seem to have a few Taiwanese
friends who, despite knowing I speak Chinese, still have this idea that I don’t
speak Chinese. Not in a malicious “we don’t want you to learn our language”
way, but in a really hilarious, although also slightly annoying, “I have to
prove to you more than once that I do in fact speak Chinese even if I am not
perfect” way. One said “Oh yes, [Cangjie] is too hard for you.” “Come on, I’m
not stupid.” “No, you’re not stupid, you’re a foreigner.” I called him out on
that and we had a good laugh. Another asked me if I could read a basic Chinese
menu after seeing me typing and replying in Chinese on Facebook for months. I
was really heartened when yet another – finally, in a show of faith – told
someone else I’d be fine at Taiwanese opera because they had Mandarin
electronic subtitles and I could read those. THANK YOU SASHA).
Another said “with other Asians we feel comfortable. With
foreigners, we like you and we’re friends with foreigners, but sometimes there
is a ‘sense of distance’, and maybe she doesn’t feel that with the new
teacher.” (translated from Chinese)
OK, but feeling a ‘sense of distance’ based solely on the
fact that I’m Big Whitey – how is that not also a subtler, and also sadder,
form of racism (even if it’s not the virulent ‘I hate foreign people’ kind)?
I mean, honestly,
I wrote yesterday about not having a "best friend" in Taiwan - I mean a female best friend, not in the way that my husband is my best friend - and while I value my foreign and local friendships equally even if we interact in different ways, I have to say I feel far greater chemistry and intuitive understanding with my Taiwanese friends than with any other random foreigner who is not my friend. Maybe I'm weird. Maybe I just don't feel that synergy or that "cultural connection" (although I feel that on some level, I must. I'm not that special after all). I don't feel a "sense of distance" with my Taiwanese friends even if we don't always have the same sort of interactions I do with other Westerners. In Chinese there's this idea of an 'unspoken understanding' or 'chemistry' (默契) - and I do feel that many locals expect that foreigners will feel 默契 with each other. Well...no. I mean, maybe on some level, sure, but I feel more 默契 with my Taiwanese friends, especially my female friends (my male friends are great but it's a different sort of friendship), than I would with any given foreigner if I didn't know them - because it's based on friendship and knowing someone, not on race and how someone looks, or even entirely on their cultural background.
So...I dunno. On some level I can sort of understand this but on another I just don't get it. Or I don't agree. I'm not sure which - still processing my thoughts there.
In the end, all I can say is that there really seems to be a
difference in how we Westerners perceive racism vs. how it’s perceived by many
Taiwanese.
This is what I was trying to say in an earlier post – especially the
fact that while we might see all foreigners as “foreigners”, locals often group
us into “high income white people” (regardless of whether we’re high income or
not – I feel we’re generally not, but then most of my students earn six figures
NT per month) and “service and factory working Southeast Asians and foreign
brides”. It’s fairly common for locals to say
外國人”
and mean “white people” – Koreans are Koreans, Japanese are Japanese, Chinese
are Chinese or “Mainlanders”, and – surprisingly – Africans and African
Americans (or black people of any other country) are not
外國人 but “black people”. Anecdotally,
my friend’s girlfriend has done this, and another local friend confirmed that
yes, a lot of people do think that way.
And – for whatever
reason, because I still don’t get it, not really – there’s an idea that it’s OK
to prefer people of your own race, regardless of their cultural upbringing,
simply because they look like you, and that’s not racism. Other things we’d
probably call “racist” would not be called so here. It’s not quite as bad as
the infamous Lonely Planet China quote from a Chinese person: “There’s no
racism in China because there are no black people in China”, but still, it’s
there.
I don’t deny that
there does seem, in any culture, to be a certain “understanding” between people
who have similar ethnic heritage and it makes sense that people would gravitate
to those who share a common cultural background, but, I don’t know, I still
feel that making business decisions based on that is, on some level, racist.
Even if it’s the way of this very unfair world. I am not sure I’d go so far as
to say that people – regardless of any language they might be learning – are
racist if they make moves towards surrounding themselves with their own race
and culture, and don’t exhibit an interest in interacting with, much less
befriending, anyone outside of that bubble, but I do question it. And I do
wonder.